广告
加载中

这种卖家电的直播 全TM骗局?

雷科技数码组 2026-07-15 11:03
雷科技数码组 2026/07/15 11:03

邦小白快读

EN
全文速览

本文曝光了家电直播测评造假的常见套路,同时给普通消费者整理了避坑实操干货,帮助大家避开骗局护住钱包。

1. 常见造假套路:直播间会找头部知名品牌产品陪跑,通过暗地清理主推款问题、故意给竞品做手脚比如堵吸风口关开关、让竞品晚开机、水军刷屏转移话题调换问题产品、水军贬低竞品等方式,造假凸显主推款优势,欺骗消费者。

2. 实用避坑方法:一是关注产品核心客观参数,不要被主播夸张话术带偏,选产品时对着核心参数核实宣传真假;二是警惕无底线捧一踩一,不知名产品大幅贬低头部品牌的基本都是提前写好剧本的骗局;三是通过多平台看真实用户评价、看电商追加评论交叉验证信息,破除信息差;四是下单前核查账号底细,没有正经测评内容的新号要高度警惕。

本文曝光了直播测评造假的行业乱象,对家电品牌的品牌运营、风险应对和产品研发都有参考价值,明确了当前消费端的传播需求。

1. 风险警示:科沃斯、石头、追觅等多个头部家电品牌都曾被不法直播间拉去陪跑,遭遇恶意打压,会误导消费者,损害品牌声誉,品牌需要建立针对虚假测评的应对机制,及时澄清不实信息。

2. 价值参考:真实专业的测评对品牌有正向价值,既可以清晰传递产品核心优势给消费者,还能反馈产品在真实使用场景中的问题,帮助品牌收集用户反馈,优化产品研发打磨。

3. 传播方向:当前消费者非常依赖测评打破信息差,品牌可以主动和正规专业测评机构合作,建立合规的传播渠道,扩大好产品的影响力,同时规避被虚假测评抹黑的风险。

本文曝光了直播测评造假的乱象,给带货家电的卖家提示了风险,也指明了合规发展的方向和可把握的机会。

1. 风险提示:这类虚假测评已经被央视财经公开曝光,属于欺骗消费者的违规行为,后续监管会持续收紧整治,卖家不要尝试这类违规套路,避免面临处罚影响自身经营。

2. 机会提示:消费者本身对产品测评有真实需求,在乱象之下,做合规真实测评的卖家反而更容易获得消费者信任,能打出差异化优势,获得更多增长机会。

3. 经营提示:如果卖家遭遇竞品的恶意打压,要及时收集证据发声维权,日常经营要聚焦产品真实参数和实际体验,做好产品品质和售后服务,积累用户真实好评,适配消费者交叉验证信息的习惯,长期获得用户信任。

本文披露了家电直播带货领域的虚假测评乱象,也给家电工厂的产品生产、营销转型带来了多方面的启示。

1. 产品生产设计启示:当前普通消费者很难读懂复杂的产品参数,更依赖实际体验的测评反馈,工厂在设计生产产品时,不能只堆参数,要更关注真实使用场景的表现,同时要重视真实测评反馈的问题,以此优化产品设计,打磨更符合用户需求的产品。

2. 商业机会启示:正规真实测评的价值在当下越来越被消费者认可,工厂可以主动和正规测评机构合作,让自身优质产品获得真实曝光,也能更好打击仿冒、劣质产品的虚假宣传,维护自身的品牌权益。

3. 电商转型启示:工厂做自营电商直播时,要走合规路线,不要搞虚假测评拉踩竞品,要建立官方真实内容传播渠道,维护自身口碑和行业正常秩序,推动长期发展。

本文分析了当前测评直播行业的发展现状和乱象,也指出了行业未来的发展方向,给做测评、直播相关的服务商提供了不少参考。

1. 核心客户痛点:C端消费者的核心痛点是产品信息不对称,面对同质化严重的家电产品不知道怎么选,同时无法分辨测评内容的真假;B端品牌厂商需要真实测评传递产品优势,同时收集真实使用体验的反馈优化产品。

2. 行业发展趋势:虚假测评已经被监管点名曝光,行业会逐步肃清乱象,未来只有正规、专业、真实的测评服务才符合发展方向,测评服务的公信力会越来越重要。

3. 发展方向:服务商可以主打真实专业测评的定位,建立公开透明的标准化测评流程,给消费者提供客观清晰的产品对比,给厂商提供真实的体验反馈,抓住乱象下的合规发展机会,打造自身的专业公信力。

本文曝光了直播间测评造假的多种套路,给直播平台的运营管理、风险规避提供了明确的改进方向。

1. 当前存在的问题:不少平台入驻的测评类直播间,存在剧本式造假带货的问题,通过不正当手段打压正规品牌,欺骗消费者,不仅损害消费者和正规品牌的利益,还会给平台带来声誉风险和监管风险。

2. 运营管理方向:平台需要加强对测评类带货直播间的资质审核,重点排查零粉丝、无过往正经内容的新号,从源头减少虚假测评账号入驻。

3. 风险规避和招商方向:平台可以主动引入正规的专业测评机构和合规卖家入驻,引导行业做真实测评内容,同时建立针对虚假测评的投诉处理机制,方便被恶意打压的品牌维权,及时清理违规直播间,肃清平台环境,规避行业乱象带来的各类风险。

本文披露了直播电商领域测评带货的新型乱象,也梳理了测评行业的价值,给产业研究提供了新的方向和参考。

1. 产业新问题:当前直播电商行业门槛低,测评带货领域衍生出新型不正当竞争乱象,造假套路多样,包括找头部品牌陪跑、给竞品做手脚、水军造势等,该乱象既损害消费者知情权,也损害正规品牌的合法利益,需要关注研究治理方案。

2. 商业模式研究:正规测评本身具备不可替代的生态价值,是连接厂商和消费者的桥梁,对消费者可以打破信息差,帮助选品,对厂商可以反馈真实使用问题,推动产品优化,真实测评的商业模式具备长期可持续性。

3. 政策启示:该领域当前缺乏明确的规范管理,需要监管出台相关规则整治虚假测评,同时平台也需要加强自律管理,才能肃清行业环境,推动直播电商测评行业良性发展,这也是重要的研究方向。

返回默认

声明:快读内容全程由AI生成,请注意甄别信息。如您发现问题,请发送邮件至 run@ebrun.com 。

我是 品牌商 卖家 工厂 服务商 平台商 研究者 帮我再读一遍。

Quick Summary

This article exposes common deceptive practices behind fake live-streamed home appliance reviews, and provides practical, actionable tips to help ordinary consumers avoid scams and protect their money.

1. Common deception tactics: Live streams use well-known top-tier brand products as "foils" to highlight a host-promoted item. Deceptive practices include hiding defects of the promoted product, secretly tampering with competing products (such as blocking air intakes or turning off power switches), delaying start-up for competitors, having paid commenters spam chats to divert attention when problems arise, switching out problematic units, and orchestrating paid attacks on competing brands, all to falsely exaggerate the advantages of the promoted product and mislead consumers.

2. Practical tips to avoid scams: First, focus on core objective product parameters rather than falling for hosts' overblown sales pitches, and verify promotional claims against these key specifications. Second, be wary of extreme one-sided praise that deliberately denigrates other products: unknown brands that sharply slam top-tier market leaders almost always follow a pre-scripted scam. Third, cross-verify information by checking real user reviews across multiple platforms and reading follow-up reviews on e-commerce sites to close information gaps. Fourth, vet the reviewer account before purchasing: new accounts with no legitimate prior review content require high vigilance.

This article exposes industry-wide malpractices of fake live-stream reviews, offering actionable insights for home appliance brands on brand operations, risk response and product development, and clarifies current communication demands from consumers.

1. Risk warning: Multiple leading home appliance brands including Ecovacs, Roborock and Dreame have been used as foils and targeted by malicious smears in fraudulent live streams. This misleads consumers and damages brand reputation, so brands need to establish response mechanisms for fake reviews to clarify misinformation in a timely manner.

2. Reference value: Authentic, professional reviews deliver positive value for brands: they clearly communicate core product advantages to consumers, and also feed back issues encountered in real-world use, helping brands collect user feedback and refine product development.

3. Communication strategy: Today's consumers heavily rely on reviews to close information asymmetries. Brands can proactively partner with legitimate, professional review institutions to build compliant communication channels, expand the influence of quality products, and reduce the risk of being targeted by fake review smears.

This article exposes the problem of fake live-stream review fraud, highlights risks for home appliance sellers, and outlines a direction for compliant growth and untapped opportunities.

1. Risk warning: These fake review practices have already been publicly exposed by CCTV Finance, and qualify as deceptive, non-compliant behavior. Regulatory scrutiny and crackdowns will continue to tighten, so sellers should avoid these deceptive tactics to escape penalties that threaten their business operations.

2. Opportunity outlook: Consumers have genuine demand for reliable product reviews. Amid widespread industry fraud, sellers that deliver compliant, authentic reviews are more likely to earn consumer trust, build a differentiated competitive advantage, and unlock greater growth opportunities.

3. Operational guidance: If sellers face malicious smears from competitors, they should collect evidence and defend their rights promptly. In daily operations, sellers should focus on real product parameters and actual user experience, prioritize product quality and after-sales service, and accumulate genuine user reviews to align with consumers' habit of cross-verifying information, and build long-term user trust.

This article discloses the fake review epidemic in live-streamed home appliance sales, and delivers multiple actionable insights for home appliance factories on product development and marketing transformation.

1. Product design and manufacturing insights: Most ordinary consumers struggle to interpret complex product parameters, and increasingly rely on review feedback based on real-world use. When designing and manufacturing products, factories should not only focus on stacking technical specifications, but pay more attention to performance in real user scenarios. They should also incorporate issues raised in authentic reviews to refine product design and build offerings that better match user demand.

2. Business opportunity insights: The value of legitimate, authentic reviews is increasingly recognized by consumers. Factories can proactively partner with formal review institutions to generate authentic exposure for their quality products, crack down on false advertising by counterfeit and low-quality goods, and protect their own brand rights.

3. E-commerce transformation insights: When factories run self-operated e-commerce live streams, they should adhere to compliant practices, avoid fake reviews and derogation of competitors, build official channels for authentic content dissemination, protect their own reputation and normal industry order, and support long-term development.

This article analyzes the current state and existing malpractices of the live review industry, outlines the industry's future development direction, and provides valuable insights for review and live-stream service providers.

1. Core client pain points: For end consumers, the core pain point is information asymmetry: consumers struggle to choose between heavily homogenized home appliance products, and cannot distinguish between authentic and fake review content. For B-side brand manufacturers, there is demand for authentic reviews that communicate product advantages, and collect real user experience feedback to improve products.

2. Industry development trend: Fake reviews have already been publicly named and exposed by regulators, so the industry will gradually clean up malpractices. Going forward, only legitimate, professional, and authentic review services align with long-term development trends, and industry credibility will become increasingly important.

3. Strategic direction: Service providers can position themselves as providers of authentic, professional reviews, build open and transparent standardized review processes, deliver objective, clear product comparisons for consumers, and provide authentic experience feedback for manufacturers. This allows them to seize compliant growth opportunities amid the industry's current chaos, and build their own professional credibility.

This article exposes multiple deceptive tactics of fake reviews in live streams, and outlines clear improvement directions for operational management and risk mitigation for live-stream platforms.

1. Existing problems: Many review-focused live streams operated by platform users engage in scripted fake sales promotion, using underhanded tactics to smears legitimate brands and deceive consumers. This not only harms the interests of consumers and legitimate brands, but also creates reputational and regulatory risks for the platform.

2. Operational management direction: Platforms need to strengthen qualification checks for review-focused sales live streams, and prioritize screening new accounts with zero followers and no history of legitimate content, to reduce the onboarding of fake review accounts at the source.

3. Risk mitigation and recruitment direction: Platforms can proactively onboard legitimate professional review institutions and compliant sellers, guide the industry to produce authentic review content, and establish a dedicated complaint handling mechanism for fake reviews to make it easier for brands targeted by malicious smears to defend their rights. Platforms should also promptly remove non-compliant live streams, clean up the platform environment, and mitigate risks stemming from industry-wide malpractices.

This article discloses the new type of malpractice in review-driven live-stream e-commerce, summarizes the value of the legitimate review industry, and provides new directions and references for industrial research.

1. New industrial problems: The live-stream e-commerce industry currently has low entry barriers, and the review-driven sales segment has given rise to new unfair competition malpractices, with a wide range of deceptive tactics including using top brands as foils, tampering with competing products, and orchestrating paid influencer hype. This malpractice undermines consumers' right to information and infringes the legitimate interests of formal brands, so further research on governance solutions is needed.

2. Business model research: Legitimate reviews deliver irreplaceable ecological value as a bridge connecting manufacturers and consumers. For consumers, they close information gaps and support product selection; for manufacturers, they feed back real-world usage issues and drive product improvement. The authentic review business model is sustainable in the long term.

3. Policy implications: This sector currently lacks clear regulatory standards. Regulators need to introduce targeted rules to crack down on fake reviews, and platforms also need to strengthen self-regulation, to clean up the industry environment and support the healthy development of the live review e-commerce sector. This is an important direction for future research.

Disclaimer: The "Quick Summary" content is entirely generated by AI. Please exercise discretion when interpreting the information. For issues or corrections, please email run@ebrun.com .

I am a Brand Seller Factory Service Provider Marketplace Seller Researcher Read it again.

雷科技数码组 | 编辑:重嘉 | 监制:罗超

直播带货的套路越来越多了。

近日,央视财经曝光了多起家电直播间测评造假案例。为了力推某款家电产品,这些直播间会设计好剧本,让它们能在所谓的对比测试中「脱颖而出」,从而刺激观众下单。但说白了,这些行为就是造假,打着测评的名义,搞误导欺骗消费者那一套。

在这个万物皆可播的时代,大家对直播天然有着眼见为实的信任感,对测评更是自带一层专业严谨的滤镜。既然眼见都不一定为实,作为普通消费者,我们到底该如何在这一场场骗局里擦亮眼睛,避开这些防不胜防的造假测评套路?

直播间「横评」看着阵仗大,

但早已内定谁赢

央视财经最近发布了三个揭露直播间骗局的短视频,第一个是扫地机器人直播测评。记者卧底位于湖南的一家贸易公司后发现,他们的大部分办公室都改装成了直播间。测评阵仗弄得很大,除了主推的几款产品外,还找来了市面上的多款知名扫地机「陪跑」。从央视财经公布的型号来看,被「迫害」的品牌有科沃斯、友望、追觅、石头等,都是清洁家电领域中的头部品牌。

如果真刀真枪的对比测评,那么这家直播间要推销的扫地机肯定上不了几个回合就会败下阵来。所以,他们选择了造假,而且用了五花八门的手段。

比如,所有洗地机完成一轮清洁测试后,直播间助理人员会在直播镜头切换的时候悄咪咪清理主推设备,处理毛发缠绕等问题,让它的清洁表现看起来更好,同时还会把机器内部的清洁布用清水打湿,以营造出清洁完毕后基站把抹布洗得干干净净的错觉。

有的时候,直播过程中主推机型还是出现瑕疵了,他们还有转移观众注意力的办法,那就是调动水军账号,在直播间里刷屏,包括询问主推设备的参数、价格等。这个时候,主播就会借机调转镜头,其他人把有问题的测试设备调换,用一模一样的新机器代替。

而且,他们还会可以打压陪跑的竞品,为了让这些设备表现差,这家直播团队准备用了很多手段,包括让机器晚15分钟开机、设备常年不清洁等,总之就是「吹黑哨」想方设法让它们落败,以凸显主推产品的优势。

在另外一家卖除螨仪的直播间,主播用的套路也大同小异,就是把用来对比的竞品的吸风口用塑料袋堵住,导致它在所谓的测评中劣势尽显,形成一种根本不干净的错觉。

央视财经还曝光了一家测评学习机的直播间,它的套路更深一点,主播伪装出客观中立的姿态,但已经提前布置好了水军,他们会在直播的时候跳出来发评论贬低对比的竞品,形成舆论假象。

还有一家直播测评洗地机的工作室就更离谱了,直接把竞品洗地机的开关关了,手指放在上面遮掩,这样主推产品就毫无悬念地实现了对其他竞品的「吊打」。

造假测评被曝光活该,

但测评本身仍然有意义

实际上,对于这类造假直播测评套路,央视已经不是第一次曝光了。更早些时候,央视就曝光过,母婴产品、水果、手机等等,任何商品,只要在所谓的测评直播间里,都有造假的案例。它们使用的套路,有的高明一点,有的低劣一点,共同目的就是用虚假手段让观众上当,把手上的商品卖出去。

其实,这种剧本式测评的套路,很多年前就有了。80、90后肯定有印象,20年前的电视购物广告,有的用到的套路就和今天直播间里的很像。比如,电视购物频道推销的DV相机,售价一两千元,但在出镜演员的手上效果比几万块的专业摄影机还好。更早些时候,火车上的商品推销员、街头的小贩,个个都有口吐莲花的绝活,总能用各种话术把手上形形色色的商品卖给目标群体。

只是,造假测评乱象固然令人深恶痛绝,当然要批评和地址,但这并不意味着我们要全盘否定测评这一内容形式。测评本身的价值,非但没有在剧本式造假中消亡,反而在如今信息大爆炸、产品同质化严重的时代显得愈发珍贵。

雷科技(ID:leitech)认为,一个合格且专业的测评者,其核心生态位恰恰介于上游厂商与下游终端消费者之间。这层中间人的身份,给了测评者不可替代的桥梁作用,能够提供一种独立且相对客观的视角,都双方都带来价值。

对于广大消费者而言,专业测评能打破信息差。面对晦涩难懂的硬件参数,比如各种名目的Mini LED分区背光方案、不同代际的OLED面板特性,或者是型号复杂、品类多样的清洁家电,普通用户很难在短时间内弄懂这些术语和参数背后的实际体验差异。

而测评者,就是替大家去体验、去当小白鼠,将枯燥的参数转化为直观的日常使用场景,在同类竞品中做横向对比,帮大家排雷避坑,让消费者能把钱花在刀刃上,挑选到真正符合自身需求的产品。

而对于厂商来说,真实、深度的测评同样有意义。一款数码或家电产品在实验室里跑出的理想数据,与在用户复杂真实的生活环境中展现出的状态往往存在偏差。优秀的测评内容不仅能够将好产品的核心优势清晰地传递给用户,还能捕捉到产品在设计、功能等等方面的不足。这些基于真实体验生成的批评与建议,也是推动厂商打磨好产品的良性反馈。

当然,测评的形式是多样化的,并不局限于专业、深度测评,只要测评者将自己的真实感受分享出来并被看到了,往往就会有意义。乔布斯时代,科技行业里有一位知名评测者——莫博士。他的测评内容吸引了大量读者,包括乔布斯。

甚至乎,他的内容能影响公司的产品研发路线。莫博士2008年在测评报告中不留情面地批评了MobileMe(iCloud前身),结果得到了乔布斯的赞赏和感谢。

莫博士对于测评的态度是真实体验和说真话,并不标榜自己客观独立,而是以一种类似于做影评的形式去测试和体验产品,给出自己的主观但真实的看法。

总而言之,行业乱象需要被肃清,是为了让真正的测评环境更加纯粹,测评本身的价值仍然存在着。测评能够给普通用户提供另一个了解产品的渠道,并成为他们选购商品的参考,同时也能够帮助厂商改进产品。

虚假测评套路深,

用户如何避坑才不被骗?

面对防不胜防的直播间造假乱象,在我们看来,普通消费者想要在精心设计的骗局中护住钱包,最核心的就是建立属于自己的信息渠道,掌握主动权。具体而言,我们可以从以下几个方面入手。

首先,是关注客观的指标,警惕极端化的情绪。在观看带货直播或评测时,不要被主播夸张的主观话术带偏,而是要将注意力放回产品的核心客观参数上。比如买扫地机器人,就看吸力大小、避障方案、电池容量;买电视,就去核实究竟是普通的背光,还是像宣传的那样采用了更先进的Mini LED或OLED面板。

此外,要高度警惕那种捧一踩一的拉踩式评测。如果一个直播间为了推销某款不知名产品,毫无底线地把行业头部品牌(比如前文提到的石头、追觅、科沃斯等)贬低得一文不值,甚至制造出除了它其他全都是工业垃圾的极端效果,那这大概率就是一场早已写好剧本的假戏。

另外,还可以多渠道交叉验证来破除信息差。具体来说,就是不要把任何单一的直播间或评测内容作为唯一的决策依据。在被种草某款产品后,可以去小红书、B站、酷安等社区平台,搜索真实用户的吐槽和拔草内容,看看大家在实际生活场景中使用这些产品遇到了什么问题。

还有一个办法,就是去电商平台看追加评价。水军一般会伪造常规的五星好评,但很难规模化地伪造使用一个月、甚至半年后的真实追评。那些关于机器故障率、耗材磨损、售后服务等方面的真实记录,往往就藏在不起眼的追评里,它们能有效破除虚假测评的滤镜。

最后要说的是,当下互联网上,「测评」的门槛被无限拉低,随便租个办公室、支起几台机器就能自称专业评测机构。因此,下单前不妨先顺手查一查带货账号的底细。从央视财经曝光的几个案例来说,其中的直播账号大部分都不是正儿八经的媒体或自媒体账号,账号下更是没有正经的测评内容,有的账号甚至是0粉丝的新号。所以,要识别他们,并没有那么难。

总之,造假评测的套路再深,说白了还是利用了消费者的信息差和冲动消费心理。只要我们稍微提高一点警惕,不盲目下单,就不会被骗。

注:文/雷科技数码组,文章来源:雷科技(公众号ID:leitech),本文为作者独立观点,不代表亿邦动力立场。

文章来源:雷科技

广告
微信
朋友圈

FAQ回顾

家电直播间常见的虚假测评套路有哪些?

常见套路包括提前内定主推产品获胜,通过镜头外清理主推设备问题、调换故障机器、故意设置陪跑竞品故障(如堵吸风口、关开关、晚开机等)造假,还会调动水军刷屏引导舆论、拉踩头部品牌凸显主推产品优势。

消费者看家电直播怎么避开虚假测评骗局?

消费者可通过四种方法避坑:一是关注产品核心客观参数,警惕极端情绪引导;二是避开捧一踩一的拉踩式评测;三是多渠道交叉验证,查看平台真实用户反馈、电商追加评价;四是下单前核实带货账号的正规性。

真实专业的产品测评有什么价值?

对消费者而言,专业测评可打破信息差,将枯燥参数转化为直观使用体验,帮助用户挑选符合自身需求的产品;对厂商而言,真实测评能反映产品实际使用的优缺点,为厂商打磨产品提供良性反馈。

央视曝光的家电虚假测评涉及哪些品类和品牌?

央视曝光的家电虚假测评涉及扫地机器人、洗地机、除螨仪、学习机等品类,造假团队常拉科沃斯、追觅、石头等清洁家电头部品牌作为陪跑竞品恶意造假。

这么好看,分享一下?

朋友圈 分享

APP内打开

赞 +1
+1
微信好友 朋友圈 新浪微博 QQ空间
关闭
收藏成功
发送
/140 0