广告
加载中

比亚迪不是车企

Eastland 2026-07-15 11:23
Eastland 2026/07/15 11:23

邦小白快读

EN
全文速览

这篇文章核心梳理了特斯拉定位转变的过程,以及对比亚迪估值逻辑变化的预判,核心干货如下:

1. 特斯拉已经成功将自身定位从传统车企转变为AI科技公司,即便目前七成营收、七成毛利润依然来自汽车业务,FSD收入仅占总营收1%,Robotaxi和人形机器人尚未实现规模化商业化,卖碳收入占2025年净利润的一半以上,且未来卖碳生意大概率因政策归零,依然获得了科技企业的高估值,市盈率远高于传统车企丰田。

2. 对比亚迪的科技实力做了量化对比,近年比亚迪研发投入已经超过特斯拉,按购买力计算达到特斯拉的2.5倍,有效专利数量至少是特斯拉的8倍,电池专利更是达到数十倍,还拥有自研4纳米智驾芯片、车规级功率半导体等硬核技术,预计两三年内比亚迪也会像特斯拉一样发生估值逻辑变化,获得科技属性的估值提升。

这篇文章对新能源汽车品牌的定位营销、价值提升有诸多参考干货,核心内容如下:

1. 品牌定位营销层面,特斯拉通过主动调整自我定位,成功从车企转变为大众和资本认可的AI科技公司,直接改变了资本市场的估值逻辑,获得了远超传统车企的市盈率溢价,这种定位调整的思路值得各类科技制造品牌参考。

2. 产业与消费趋势层面,当前汽车产业的科技属性已经成为核心竞争力,资本和消费者都越来越看重品牌的自研技术实力,自动驾驶、芯片、储能、功率半导体这些硬核科技已经成为品牌溢价的核心支撑。

3. 对比数据显示,比亚迪在研发投入、专利储备上都已经远超特斯拉,只要强化自身科技属性,未来品牌价值还有非常大的提升空间,给国内制造品牌提供了可参考的成长路径。

本文梳理了新能源汽车行业的现状与未来变化,给相关汽车卖家、从业者整理了明确的风险与机会,干货如下:

1. 风险提示层面:特斯拉依赖的卖碳生意受美国政策变化影响,未来大概率会归零,给所有依赖政策红利的相关业务敲响了警钟;FSD、Robotaxi、人形机器人这些新业务目前都还处于早期阶段,变现困难,商业化和产能都有极高不确定性,布局相关概念业务需要警惕泡沫风险。

2. 机会提示层面:新能源汽车产业已经完成从传统制造向科技制造的升级,拥有核心自研技术的品牌估值会逐步抬升,相关配件、整车销售卖家可以优先绑定有硬核研发实力的品牌,获得更多增长空间;另外自动驾驶落地的核心瓶颈是兜底能力,相关增值服务有很大的创新机会。

本文对整车及零部件工厂的未来发展方向给出了不少启示,核心干货整理如下:

1. 产品生产与设计需求层面:当下汽车产业对产品科技含量的要求越来越高,芯片、功率半导体、动力电池这些核心零部件,只有自研才能掌握竞争力,市场和消费者都越来越认可拥有硬核技术的产品,工厂需要逐步向核心技术自研方向转型。

2. 商业机会层面:随着特斯拉布局人形机器人量产,新的智能硬件赛道开始启动,给相关零部件工厂带来了新的增长机会,但也要注意,人形机器人目前还面临极大的产能不确定性,大概率会遭遇产能地狱,布局相关业务需要保持谨慎,不能盲目扩张。

3. 数字化升级启示:制造工厂的核心竞争力已经转向研发和专利,加大研发投入、积累核心专利,才能在产业升级中获得足够话语权,享受到科技属性带来的溢价。

本文梳理了新能源汽车和AI出行领域的行业变化,给相关服务商整理了行业趋势、客户痛点和方向,干货如下:

1. 行业发展趋势:汽车产业已经从传统制造赛道正式切换到AI科技赛道,不管是资本市场还是消费端,都认可科技属性带来的溢价,自动驾驶、人形机器人、智能出行都已经成为明确的未来核心增长方向,相关服务商可以提前布局这些领域。

2. 客户核心痛点:特斯拉推广Robotaxi的最大瓶颈是兜底能力不足,至今无法实现完全脱离人工的商业化落地;特斯拉原来坚持的纯视觉路线无法满足人形机器人多传感融合的需求,技术路线需要调整。

3. 解决方案方向:比亚迪已经实现了数百万级用户的智驾兜底,给行业提供了成熟可参考的样本,AI技术服务商、出行运营服务商可以围绕智驾兜底、多模态传感融合这些方向开发解决方案,契合行业当前的真实需求。

本文给涉及新能源汽车、科技制造的平台商提供了不少风向和运营参考,核心干货如下:

1. 当前产业对平台的需求:越来越多的科技制造企业希望摆脱传统制造的定位,获得科技企业对应的资源和估值,平台需要调整对制造企业的评判标准,认可科技制造企业的科技属性,适配企业的新需求。

2. 风向规避:当前不少科技制造企业的新业务还停留在概念阶段,变现能力差,商业化落地不确定性极高,平台在招商、合作的时候需要注意甄别概念泡沫,核心要关注技术落地、营收利润这些硬指标,不能被概念忽悠。

3. 运营与招商方向:平台可以重点引入拥有硬核研发实力、大量核心专利储备的科技制造企业,这类企业未来增长空间大,像比亚迪这类研发投入超过特斯拉、专利储备数倍于特斯拉的企业,估值还有很大提升空间,属于优质的合作标的。

本文提出了汽车产业估值逻辑的新变化,梳理了产业转型的新动向,给产业研究提供了很多新的研究方向,干货如下:

1. 产业新动向:传统车企向科技企业转型已经成为明确的新趋势,特斯拉已经完成了定位转换,成功获得了科技企业的估值,比亚迪接下来也会经历同样的估值逻辑重构,汽车产业已经不再是单纯的传统制造业,科技属性成为产业的核心新特征。

2. 估值逻辑的新变化:当前资本市场对企业的估值不再完全绑定当前的营收利润结构,更看重企业未来的科技成长空间,特斯拉七成营收来自造车,依然获得了六七倍于传统车企龙头丰田的市值,就是科技定位带来的估值红利,这种新的估值逻辑值得深入研究。

3. 值得关注的新问题:FSD、Robotaxi、人形机器人这些新业务都还处于早期,商业化变现困难,技术路线也存在不确定性,核心研发投入和专利储备成为科技制造企业的核心竞争力,这些新特征都是产业研究值得关注的新方向。

返回默认

声明:快读内容全程由AI生成,请注意甄别信息。如您发现问题,请发送邮件至 run@ebrun.com 。

我是 品牌商 卖家 工厂 服务商 平台商 研究者 帮我再读一遍。

Quick Summary

This article outlines the evolution of Tesla’s brand positioning and projects an upcoming shift in BYD’s valuation logic, with key takeaways as follows:

1. Tesla has successfully repositioned itself from a traditional automaker to an AI technology company. Even today, 70% of its revenue and 70% of its gross profit still come from auto sales, while FSD revenue accounts for only 1% of total revenue. Robotaxi and humanoid robots have yet to achieve large-scale commercialization, and carbon credit sales are expected to make up more than half of Tesla’s net profit in 2025 — a business that will likely be eliminated entirely by policy shifts in the future. Even with these fundamentals, Tesla now commands a high tech-sector valuation, with a price-to-earnings ratio far exceeding that of traditional automaker Toyota.

2. The article provides a quantitative comparison of technological strength between BYD and Tesla. BYD’s R&D investment has already outpaced Tesla’s in recent years, reaching 2.5 times Tesla’s spending when adjusted for purchasing power parity. BYD holds at least 8 times more active patents than Tesla, and dozens of times more battery-related patents. It also owns proprietary core technologies including a 4nm autonomous driving chip and automotive-grade power semiconductors. The article projects that within two to three years, BYD will undergo a similar valuation logic shift to Tesla, unlocking a higher technology-aligned valuation.

This article offers valuable insights for positioning and value enhancement for new energy vehicle (NEV) brands, with key takeaways as follows:

1. In terms of brand positioning and marketing, Tesla proactively reshaped its identity to transition from a traditional automaker to an AI technology company recognized by both the public and capital markets. This shift directly rewrote its valuation logic on Wall Street, delivering a P/E premium far above that of traditional automakers — a repositioning strategy that offers a useful framework for all tech manufacturing brands.

2. For industry and consumer trends: The technological attributes of automobiles have now become the core source of competitive advantage. Both capital and consumers increasingly prioritize in-house R&D capability, and hard technologies including autonomous driving, chips, energy storage and power semiconductors have become the core drivers of brand premium.

3. Comparative data shows BYD already outpaces Tesla by a wide margin in both R&D investment and patent reserves. If BYD continues to strengthen its technology positioning, it has substantial room for brand value growth, offering a replicable growth path for Chinese manufacturing brands.

This article outlines the current state and upcoming shifts in the NEV industry, and clarifies key risks and opportunities for auto sellers and industry practitioners, with key takeaways as follows:

1. Risk warnings: Tesla’s carbon credit business, a major profit driver, is highly likely to be eliminated by U.S. policy changes, sounding an alarm for all businesses reliant on policy subsidies. New businesses including FSD, Robotaxi and humanoid robots are still in early stages, face major monetization challenges, and carry extremely high uncertainty around commercialization and production scale. Companies looking to enter these concept-driven segments should be wary of asset bubbles.

2. Opportunity outlook: The NEV industry has completed its upgrade from traditional manufacturing to technology-enabled manufacturing. Brands with core proprietary technology will see their valuations rise gradually. Auto sellers, both of complete vehicles and components, can prioritize partnerships with brands that have strong in-house R&D to unlock greater growth. Additionally, the core bottleneck for autonomous driving commercialization is fallback capability, creating major innovation opportunities for related value-added services.

This article offers key insights for the future development of automakers and auto component factories, with key takeaways as follows:

1. For product manufacturing and design requirements: The auto industry now demands far higher technological content from products. Core components including chips, power semiconductors and power batteries only deliver competitive advantage when developed in-house, as both the market and consumers increasingly favor products built on proprietary hard technology. Factories need to gradually transition to developing core technologies in-house.

2. For business opportunities: Tesla’s push for mass production of humanoid robots has launched a new smart hardware track, bringing new growth opportunities for relevant component factories. However, humanoid robots still face extreme production uncertainty and will most likely encounter a "capacity hell" scenario. Factories looking to enter this space should proceed with caution and avoid overexpansion.

3. Insights for digital transformation: The core competitiveness of manufacturing factories has shifted to R&D and patents. Only by increasing R&D investment and accumulating core patents can companies gain greater bargaining power amid industry upgrading and capture the valuation premium brought by technology positioning.

This article outlines industry shifts in NEVs and AI-powered mobility, and summarizes key industry trends, customer pain points and strategic directions for relevant service providers, with key takeaways as follows:

1. Industry development trends: The auto industry has officially shifted from a traditional manufacturing track to an AI technology track. Both capital markets and consumers now value the premium brought by technology positioning, and autonomous driving, humanoid robots and smart mobility have emerged as clear core growth areas for the future. Relevant service providers can prepare by positioning to enter these segments early.

2. Core customer pain points: The biggest bottleneck for Tesla’s Robotaxi rollout is insufficient fallback capability, and the service has yet to achieve full commercial launch without human oversight. Tesla’s long-held pure camera vision approach cannot meet the multi-sensor fusion requirements of humanoid robots, requiring a major adjustment to its technical roadmap.

3. Directions for solutions: BYD has already implemented mature autonomous driving fallback capability for millions of users, offering a proven industry reference. AI technology providers and mobility operation service providers can develop solutions focused on autonomous driving fallback and multi-modal sensor fusion, addressing the most pressing current needs of the industry.

This article offers strategic guidance and operational references for platforms operating in NEVs and tech manufacturing, with key takeaways as follows:

1. Current industry demands from platforms: A growing number of tech manufacturing companies are looking to shed their traditional manufacturing positioning to access tech-sector resources and valuations. Platforms need to adjust their evaluation criteria for manufacturing firms, recognize the technology attributes of tech-enabled manufacturers, and adapt to enterprises’ new positioning needs.

2. Risk mitigation: Many new businesses from tech manufacturing firms remain at the concept stage, have weak monetization capability, and carry extremely high uncertainty around commercial launch. When sourcing merchants and forming partnerships, platforms should screen out concept-driven hype, and prioritize hard metrics including technology commercialization progress, revenue and profit rather than getting swayed by buzzwords.

3. Operations and sourcing direction: Platforms can prioritize onboarding tech manufacturing companies with strong in-house R&D and large reserves of core patents, as these companies have substantial future growth upside. Companies like BYD, which already outspends Tesla on R&D and holds multiple times more patents, have large room for valuation upside and represent high-quality partnership targets.

This article identifies a new shift in the valuation logic of the auto industry and outlines new trends in industrial transformation, opening up new research directions for industry scholars, with key takeaways as follows:

1. New industry trends: The transition of traditional automakers to technology companies has become a clear new trend. Tesla has already completed its positioning shift and secured a tech-sector valuation, and BYD will next go through the same valuation logic restructuring. The auto industry is no longer purely a traditional manufacturing sector, and technological attributes have become its core new characteristic.

2. New shifts in valuation logic: Capital markets no longer tie corporate valuation entirely to current revenue and profit structures, and instead place greater weight on a company’s future technology growth potential. The fact that Tesla, which generates 70% of its revenue from auto manufacturing, holds a market capitalization six to seven times that of traditional auto leader Toyota, is evidence of the valuation dividend brought by technology positioning. This new valuation logic merits further in-depth research.

3. New topics for research: New businesses including FSD, Robotaxi and humanoid robots are still in early stages, face challenges with commercial monetization, and carry uncertainty around technical roadmaps. Core R&D investment and patent reserves have become the core competitive advantage for tech manufacturing companies, and all these new features represent emerging research directions worth attention for industry scholars.

Disclaimer: The "Quick Summary" content is entirely generated by AI. Please exercise discretion when interpreting the information. For issues or corrections, please email run@ebrun.com .

I am a Brand Seller Factory Service Provider Marketplace Seller Researcher Read it again.

作者|Eastland

2025年,丰田全球销量超过1000万辆、净利润300亿美元,市值2200亿美元,市盈率不到10倍。

特斯拉销量、净利润仅为丰田零头。如被视为车企,市值也只是丰田的零头。但按科技企业估值,市盈率超过400倍、市值1.5万亿美元,相当于6.7个丰田!

特斯拉也曾被视为车企,尽管科技属性突出,市场仍紧盯销量、毛利润率、净利润、经营现金流。

2020年10月FSD早期版本开始测试,赚足眼球。马斯克及时定调:特斯拉是AI公司,汽车/机器人只是技术的载体。如今,特斯拉科技公司身份已经固化,市场对其汽车业务的疲软视而不见。

比亚迪销量远超特斯拉,市值却只有1200亿美元、不到特斯拉的8%。但是,从研发投入、专利数、重磅新技术落地等维度,比亚迪科研实力可圈可点。从闪充到智驾兜底,从车规级功率半导体称雄到自研4纳米智驾芯片,比亚迪的科技属性获得日益广泛的认知。

两三年内,发生在特斯拉身上的估值逻辑变化就会发生在比亚迪身上。

特斯拉自我定位的变迁

2010年,特斯拉招股时将自己定义为纯正的车企:

We design,develop,manufacture and sell high-performance fully electric vehicles and advanced electric vehicle powertrain components.

此后多年都是这样表述,直到2016年增加光伏及储能系统:

We design,develop,manufacture and sell high-performance fully electric vehicles,and energy storage systems,as well as install,operate and maintain solar and energy storage products.

2021年确定了使命:

Our missiong is to accelerate the wordl’s transition to sustainable energy.

2025年,特斯拉的自我定位凝练且精明:

We are focused on bringing AI into the real world,through products and services like FSD(Supervised)and Robotaxi,as well as working to develop and commercialize AI robots(including Optimus).

三十来个单词,强调了自己的AI属性,铺陈了三大主要卖点——FSD、无人出租车、人形机器人。

Supervised(受监督的)这个单词最妙——充当关键的免责声明。它告诉大家,FSD虽然名为Full Self-Driving(完全自动驾驶),但人类驾驶员必须全程监控、随时准备接管并承担全部事故责任。

实际上还是造车的

1)七成营收来自卖车

特斯拉汽车业务包含整车销售、碳排放配额和租赁。

2023年,营收达到峰值842亿美元,占总营收的85.2%。其中:

碳排放配额收入17.9亿美元;

租赁收入21.2亿美元;

2025年,汽车业务收入回落到695亿美元、占总营收的73.3%。其中:

整车销售收入658亿美元、较2023年下降16.2%;

碳排放配额收入19.9亿美元、较2023年增长11.3%,但同比下降27.9%。

租赁收入17.1亿美元、较2023年下降19.2%;

整车业务亦贡献了七成毛利润。以2025年为例,整车业务毛利润123.6亿美元、占毛利润总额的72.3%。

七成营收及毛利润来自汽车销售,人形机器人、无人出租车还没有影子,特斯拉却已不被视为车企!

2)五成利润来自“卖碳”

碳排放配额(Automotive Regulatory Credits)业务收入即纯利,是特斯拉利润的重要支柱。

2020年,特斯拉已奋斗17年终于扭亏,净利润8.6亿美元 ,而出售碳排放配额的收入达15.8亿美元。

随着汽车业务盈利能力增强,“卖碳”业务对净利润的贡献大幅下降:

2023年,净利润达到创纪录的150亿美元,17.9亿美元“卖碳”收入仅相当于净利润的12%;

……

2025年,“卖碳”收入疲软、同比下降27.9%;净利润下降更猛、降幅超过46%;“卖碳”收入与净利润的比例提高到51.7%;

2025年Q1,“卖碳”收入下降36.1%至3.8亿,相当于净利润的77.4%。

因政策变化,美国车企不再为生产燃油车支付合规成本,特斯拉的“卖碳”生意大概率归零。

2026年Q1,整车业务毛利润34.2亿,毛利润率21.1%。剔除零成本的卖碳收入(3.8亿美元),毛利润率降至18.7%。

丰田不配做特斯拉的天花板

1)FSD——仅占营收的1%

FSD业务收到的现金被归为“递延收入”,买断模式按解锁功能进度确认营收,订阅模式按直线法确认营收。

特斯拉不被视为车企,主要因为有FSD。但这项收入占营收的比例“很卑微”:

2022年,确认FSD收入5.8亿美元、相当于营收的0.71%、相当于研发费用的18.9%;

2023年,确认FSD收入6亿美元、相当于营收的0.61%、相当于研发费用的15%;

2024年,确认FSD收入11.9亿美元、相当于营收的1.22%、相当于研发费用的26.2%;

2025年,确认FSD收入9.6亿美元、相当于营收的1.01%、相当于研发费用的20.7%;

FSD收入仅占营收的百分之一,连研发费用都没赚回来,但足以令投资人相信特斯拉是科技企业。

2)无人出租车、人形机器人

无人出租车

截至2026年7月,在全美投入试运营的车辆仅67辆,其中42辆在德州。此前在加州旧金山湾区投放158辆试运营(带安全员的包车模式),现只保留10辆用于道路测试、不载客。

原计划2026年上半年落地凤凰城、奥兰多、坦帕、拉斯维加斯四座城市。目前仍处于筹备阶段,尚未投入任何对外运营的Robotaxi车辆。

推广无人出租车的最大瓶颈是特斯拉的兜底能力,因为乘客不承担责任。

为了控制风险,特斯拉规定无人出租车服务只在天气良好的白天开放,且只能在限速不超过64公里的道路上行驶。在德州试运营的42辆“无人出租车”都没有脱离人工干预——28辆车上配备了安全员,另外14辆通过远程监控。

最新估计,2026年内将投入100辆测试车,其中20辆无安全员、无远程监控,

与特斯拉形成鲜明对比的是,比亚迪为“天神之眼”用户兜底(截至2026年5月末达315万、日行驶量程约2亿公里),车上没有安全员!

人形机器人

据悉特斯拉人形机器人即将量产,加州弗里蒙特工厂Model S/Y已正式停产,为Optimus腾地儿。

坊间估计Optimus V3的BOM价为6万美元。

7月1日,马斯克参观弗里蒙特工厂并晒出与30位工程师的合照。越临近交卷,他的话风越谨慎——“产能提高将极其缓慢”、“根本不可能预测”、“不像造汽车”,明显开始预期管理。不出意外的话,Model 3遭遇过的“产能地狱”会降临到Optimus身上。Model 3有上海超级工厂解围,Optimus的救星在哪里?

据悉,Optimus将搭载自研AI5推理芯片。特斯拉将纯视觉捧上神坛,核心逻辑是“数据一致性”和“避免传感器信号相互干扰”、“处理多种信号导致系统变慢”。但人形机器人不可能是纯视觉的,声音、力度、温度都必不可少并实现毫秒级融合。

事实上,特斯拉新一代智驾芯片(AI5)已具备多模态信号的高频实时整合处理能力,可同步处理视觉、激光雷达、毫米波雷达的多路信号,激光雷达也已跌至千元级。FSD放弃纯视觉方案万事俱备、顺理成章。以马斯克的口才,一定能让世人心悦诚服。

尽管特斯拉是科技企业的几个证据都有瑕疵,但足以令丰田不配做特斯拉估值的天花板。

3)比亚迪科技股成色

先看两个硬指标:研发投入和专利数量。

研发投入

2022年,比亚迪、特斯拉研发投入分别为200亿和210亿(人民币),“比特比”为97%;

2023年,比亚迪研发投入大幅超越特斯拉,“比特比”达143%;

2024年,比亚迪研发投入54亿,比特斯拉高68%;

2025年,比亚迪研发投入630亿、“比特比”回落到139%;

如果按购买力评价(1美元兑换3人民币),比亚迪研发投入达到特斯拉的2.5倍!

专利数

截至2025年末,比亚迪全球范围内公开专利7.1万项,其中4.2万项已获得授权(注:专利制度的本质就是以公开换取保护,除非涉及国防、国家安全,想获得授权必须公开相关技术细节)。

特斯拉专利情况比较复杂,不同机构、不同口径的数据有很大差异。例如,GreB数据显示2024年有效专利2511项;另有机构将认为,将有效专利与正在申请的专利合计,总数在6000~7000项;还有机构认为特斯拉拥有97项电池专利(比亚迪有数千项电池专利)

比亚迪有效专利数至少是特斯拉的8倍。其中,电池专利数是特斯拉的数十倍。

综上所述,尽管特斯拉FSD变现能力弱,纯视觉大概率是“弯路”,其科技属性毋庸置疑。但如果只承认特斯拉是科技股,而比亚迪是纯车企就有失偏颇了。

丰田同样不配做比亚迪估值的天花板。丰田有自研4纳米智驾芯片吗?有全球第一的车规级功率半导体吗?有全球出货量第一的储能吗?有充电功率达兆瓦级的动力电池吗?如果答案是否的,凭什么做比亚迪的天花板?

*以上分析仅供参考,不构成任何投资建议!

注:文/Eastland,文章来源:虎嗅APP(公众号ID:huxiu_com),本文为作者独立观点,不代表亿邦动力立场。

文章来源:虎嗅APP

广告
微信
朋友圈

FAQ回顾

为什么比亚迪不应被归类为传统车企?

比亚迪科研实力突出,拥有自研4纳米智驾芯片、全球第一的车规级功率半导体、全球出货量第一的储能、兆瓦级充电功率动力电池;2025年研发投入达630亿,全球公开专利7.1万项,有效专利数至少是特斯拉的8倍,科技属性已获广泛认可。

特斯拉的市值为什么远高于传统车企丰田?

特斯拉已明确自身AI公司定位,核心布局FSD、无人出租车、人形机器人三大科技业务,市场按科技企业给予其估值,2025年市盈率超400倍、市值达1.5万亿美元,相当于6.7个丰田,而丰田作为传统车企市盈率不到10倍。

比亚迪的智驾体系有哪些优势?

比亚迪自研4纳米智驾芯片,推出“天神之眼”智驾系统,官方为所有用户提供智驾兜底责任,截至2026年5月末该系统用户规模达315万,日均行驶里程约2亿公里,用户行驶时车辆无需配备安全员。

特斯拉FSD业务的营收占比是多少?

特斯拉FSD收入占总营收的比例极低,2022年至2025年的占比分别为0.71%、0.61%、1.22%、1.01%,尚未覆盖对应的研发投入,却已成为市场认定其科技属性的核心依据之一。

这么好看,分享一下?

朋友圈 分享

APP内打开

赞 +1
+1
微信好友 朋友圈 新浪微博 QQ空间
关闭
收藏成功
发送
/140 0